Your Right to Present Witnesses at Trial in Florida

If you’re facing criminal charges in Florida and choose to go to trial, it’s crucial to understand one of your most fundamental rights: the right to present relevant witnesses in your defense. This right is guaranteed under Article I, Section 9 of the Florida Constitution, and it can make all the difference in the outcome of your case.

At Fighter Law, we’re committed to ensuring our clients receive fair trials, proper representation, and that every relevant voice is heard.

Recent Legal Win Reinforces This Right

In the case of Karls, Jr. v. State of Florida, the Second District Court of Appeal reversed a trial court’s decision that had prevented the defendant’s mother from testifying at trial. Karls had been charged with DUI with property damage, and his mother was prepared to testify that she had not seen him consume any alcohol or drugs prior to his arrest. Despite this, the prosecution objected, claiming her testimony was irrelevant, and the trial court sustained the objection—blocking her from speaking to the jury.

Karls was ultimately convicted and sentenced to jail time, probation, and a license suspension.

However, on appeal, the court found that the mother’s testimony was both relevant and significant in challenging the State’s burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The appellate court ruled that Karls’s constitutional right to present a defense had been violated, and the conviction was overturned, granting him a new trial.

Why This Matters for You

This case serves as a powerful reminder that every defendant has the right to present evidence and testimony that supports their defense and that courts must uphold this right. If you’re facing criminal charges, whether it’s DUI, drug possession, or any other allegation, you need an attorney who will fight to make sure your side of the story is fully heard.

Fighter Law is Here to Protect Your Rights

We don’t just show up—we strategize, investigate, and advocate. We identify key witnesses, build strong defenses, and ensure your constitutional rights are never pushed aside.

If you’re ready to fight your case and want a team that truly understands how to protect your rights in trial, contact Fighter Law today.

We fight because we care.

Attorney Clyde Lemon

Share: