Domestic Violence Injunctions

Obtaining a domestic violence injunction in Florida is not all that hard.  The Courts will require that you demonstrate (by competent substantial evidence) that you have been the victim of domestic violence OR that you are in imminent danger of becoming a victim of domestic violence.

Therefore, you have to show two things:

  1. The respondent is or was a household member; and

  2. The respondent stalked, battered, sexually battered or assaulted, kidnapped or falsely imprisoned you.

A “household member” encompasses many different types of relationships.  The definition includes spouses and former spouses, any persons related by blood or marriage, any persons who reside or have resided as a family in the past, or persons who have a child in common.

So even though you never lived in the same “household” as the other person, you are considered a “household member” if you had a child with that person.

Having a domestic violence injunction (while not a criminal offense) can prevent you from getting or keeping a concealed weapons permit in the State of Florida.  Call us at 407-344-4837 to learn more.

What is Domestic Violence?

Domestic violence is any assault, aggravated assault, battery, aggravated battery, sexual assault, sexual battery, stalking, aggravated stalking, kidnapping, false imprisonment, or any criminal offense resulting in physical injury or death of one family household member by another

When is a domestic violence injunction applicable?

According to Florida Law 741.30(6)(a), “A domestic violence injunction may be issued upon notice and hearing, when it appears to the court that a petitioner is either the victim of domestic violence as defined by section 741.28 or has reasonable cause to believe he or she is in imminent danger of becoming a victim of domestic violence.”

Therefore, you have to show two things:

  1. The respondent is or was a household member; and
  2. The respondent stalked, battered, sexually battered or assaulted, kidnapped or falsely imprisoned you.

A “household member” encompasses many different types of relationships.  The definition includes spouses and former spouses, any persons related by blood or marriage, any persons who reside or have resided as a family in the past, or persons who have a child in common.

So even though you never lived in the same “household” as the other person, you are considered a “household member” if you had a child with that person.

Does it matter when the incident happened?

The Florida Supreme Court has held that there is a temporal component to filling for a domestic violence injunction. While that is not specified, it is important because you need to provide evidence of domestic violence that is reasonable and competent, the court may not accept an isolated incident as reason to issue an injunction.

For example consider the recent Florida Supreme Court decision in Zapiola v. Kordecki. The two women had been in a relationship in 2012. During that time there was a night that Kordecki claimed Zapiola “threw a drink at her and punched her in the face.” After that Kordecki said that Zapiola had tried to contact her through social media and that her job as a traffic aid may present Xapiola with the opportunity to harm her. The court decided that the one incident identified years ago by Kordecki is not “reasonable cause to believe that she was in imminent danger of becoming a victim of domestic violence.” The court also found that the messages sent over social media were not objectively reasonable.

In the context, objectively reasonable means that the fear experienced in the case was not a fear that would be felt by a reasonable, unbiased person. For example, if for some reason your boss yelled “I’m going to kill you,” and you were in a public place and he/she did not have a gun pointed at you, then it is reasonable to think that he/she will not actually kill you. Therefore the fear felt alone is not reasonable cause to file for an injunction. Similarly, the messages sent by Zapiola to Kordecki did not adequately show that Kordecki was or will be in danger.

What if I am experiencing verbal violence?

The Florida Supreme Court has found that “verbal violence, mental instability, a bad temper, depressive and suicidal statements, angry messages, vague actions, and general conditional future threats without overt action implying imminence have been found to be insufficient.” In other words, if the person is being mean or exhibits “uncivil behavior” along with actions that a typical of a crumbling domestic relationship, that is not sufficient grounds for this kind of injunction.